The 17 Best Eyeliner for Waterline Reviews & Guide 2023

The makeup world brings in yet new trends and techniques to make you look beautiful by enhancing your features. And when it comes to makeup, the eyes always stand first in line. Ever since eye makeup began, applying kohl in the waterline area was the most basic technique. While the makeup techniques grew far and wide, the artists have fallen back to the old-school technique which is often called ‘tightening’, these days.

The technique creates the illusion of bigger eyes and heavy eyelashes, without looking too ‘made-up’. Therefore, it helps enhance your eyes more subtly and naturally.

But not every eyeliner can be applied to your sensitive waterline. So, we have researched on the best Eyeliner for waterline. However, first, you need to look at the buying guide to help you make a learned decision.

Eyeliner buying guide

There are 2 types of eyeliners suitable for water lining-gel and pencil. Both the eyeliners are easy to use, while gel comes in handy, you need to resharpen the pencil eyeliners for most of the time. But what is more important is to understand the texture and ingredients. If the eyeliner contains harmful pigments, these might irritate your eyes so look for dermatologically tested or allergy and irritant-free formulas.

Best Eyeliner for Waterline in 2023

Annabelle Waterline Matte Kohl Eyeliner

To enhance the look of your eyes and make them appear big, opt for this kohl eyeliner. Whether you like matte or luminous, you have both options available. Specially formulated for the waterline, it is easy to use and wear for long-hours without smudge.

Pros:

• Available in shades of black, beige, and lavender
• A Gel eyeliner
• Waterproof and transfer-proof
• A hypoallergenic and fragrance-free product

Cons:

• Hard to define any

L’Oréal Paris Makeup Infallible Never Fail Original Mechanical Pencil Eyeliner with Built-in Sharpener

This one is a mechanical eye-pencil, that is easy for the novice makeup doers out there. You can easily sharpen the tip with the built-in sharpener. A long last cosmetic, it won’t smudge or fade as you go along living your day.

Pros:

• Available in shades of black, brown, white, and navy
• A pencil eyeliner
• Long-lasting with a 16-hour stay

Cons:

• Didn’t find any

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil

If you like your eyes to pop out and dazzle, you can choose the unique shades of greens and blues by NYX Professional. A mechanical eye pencil, you won’t need to re-sharpen it time and again, just twist and use and twist back after you are done. Be it sunny or rainy, this eyeliner will stay put on your eyes.

Pros:

• Available in 15 different shades of black, brown, green, blue, and white
• A pencil eyeliner
• Smudge-proof and water-proof
• Long-lasting with 16hour stay
• A vegan and PETA certified cruelty free formula

Cons:

• Hard to find any

VASANTI Kajal Waterline Eyeliner

If sensitivity is your issue, then this waterline eyeliner might be the product to go for. It is completely safe and will last long on your eyes, without any form of irritation or smudge. Just don’t forget to re-twist it, since it is non-retractable for hygiene.

Pros:

• Available in shades of black, and brown
• A pencil eyeliner (non-retractable)
• Smudge-proof and water-proof
• Dermatologist and Ophthalmologically tested formula
• The eyeliner is formulated without parabens or gluten
• A vegan and cruelty-free formula

Cons:

• Hard to find any

Immovable black eyeliner by Mia Adora

If you are looking for bold makeup, and extra-dark eyeliner that can be used for your cat-eye and also for your waterline, this eyeliner might be a good choice. It is an easy to use eyeliner pencil that comes with a sharpener.

Pros:

• Available in ultra-carbon black shade
• Safe for contact-lenses
• A pencil eyeliner
• Smudge-proof and water-proof
• Long-lasting with a 10-hour stay
• A paraben and cruelty-free formula

Cons;

• Hard to find any

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eyeliner Pencil

This eyeliner will surely lead you to the party next door. With Urban Decay you have a crazy choice of colors in glitter, cream, shimmer, matte and metallic finish. This eyeliner pencil won’t let your stay put but will last long on your eyes while you enjoy your party all day long. Thanks to the hydrating and creamy formula, with jojoba oil, vitamin E, and cottonseed oil, it helps soften the area around the eyes.

Pros:

• Available in 25 plus colors in matte/glitter/cream/metallic/shimmer
• Long-lasting and quick-drying formula
• A pencil eyeliner, with a sharpener
• Smudge-proof and water-proof
• A cruelty-free formula

Cons:

• None found so far

Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel Eye Liner Pencil

A gel-based eyeliner that would enhance the color of your eyes and make your eye appear bigger and beautiful. Once you put it on, you can be assured of the fact that it will stay in your eyes for as long as 24 hours, in the same state as you applied it.

Pros:

• Available in shades of black and brown
• Long-lasting with 24-hour wear
• A water, smudge, heat, and humidity proof eyeliner
• A gel-based eyeliner
• An Ophthalmologist tested formula
• Suitable for contact lens wearers and those with sensitive eyes

Cons:

• None found so far

Covergirl Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner Pencil

If you are not sure whether to waste time sharpening an eye pencil, you can go for a self-sharpening eye pencil like this one. This is because the tip is specially designed to be sharp with usage. All you need is to pick up the perfect shade. Also, to help you get a bold and smoky look, it comes with a smudger.

Pros:

• Available in different shades of black, blue, and brown
• A pencil eyeliner with a smudger
• Leaping Bunny certified cruelty free

Cons:

• Hard to find any

Maybelline New York Tattoo studio Waterproof, Long Wearing, Eyeliner Pencil

If you are somebody you can party straight up to midnight or else, could have a nap and move on to the next one, then you need this gel-eye pencil in your house. You might not even carry it along, since it will stay on your eyes as long as you want to let it stay, without budging.

Pros:

• Available in 9 different shades of black, brown, blue, grey, etc.
• Long-lasting with 36-hour wear
• A waterproof, smudge, fade, and sweat-resistant formula
• A crayon-gel based eyeliner (Sharpen able)

Cons:

• Hard to find any

IT COSMETICS No-Tug Waterproof Gel Eyeliner

Not only would this gel eyeliner make your eyes look beautiful, but help them remain so. This is because the eyeliner is infused with anti-aging technology and has the benefits of Hydrolyzed Collagen, Silk Proteins, and Vitamins C and E. Also, due to its trademark no-tug technology, it will glide smoothly on your eyes resulting in a smooth application.

Pros:

• Available in shades of black and brown
• Can last up to 8 hours
• A waterproof eyeliner
• A gel-based eyeliner
• A paraben, fragrance, sulfate-free formula

Cons:

• Hard to find any

Wunder2 SUPER-STAY Makeup Eyeliner Pencil

Another great option for those of you who want to make a statement with your eyes. Be it metallic, glitter, or matte, you have different options for different kinds of occasions. A pencil eyeliner that will last long and retain the marvelous look on your eyes without any form of smudge.

Pros:

• Available in 21 different shades such as black, brown, blue, green, pink, gold, etc.
• Available in 3 types of finish-metallic, glitter, or essential matte
• Water, transfer, and smudge-proof eyeliner
• A pencil eyeliner
• Can last up to 24 hours
• Leaping Bunny certified cruelty free

Cons:

• None so far

Palladio Retractable Waterproof Eyeliner

A crayon-like pencil eyeliner that has the benefits of botanicals and vitamins. Therefore, it wouldn’t only give you a long-lasting beautiful eye, but also help to nourish the area around it. Moreover, this eye pencil doesn’t even need sharpening.

Pros:

• Available in different shades such black, brown, blue, and olive
• A water and smudge-proof eyeliner
• A pencil eyeliner (Retractable)
• A cruelty and paraben-free product

Cons:

• Didn’t find any

e.l.f, No Budge Retractable Eyeliner

For an all-day bold and smudge-free look, opt for this retractable pencil eyeliner by e.l.f. The good news is, that it doesn’t harm your eyes since it is devoid of several harmful ingredients, making it safe to be used on your waterline.

Pros:

• Available in shades of black, charcoal, and coffee
• A water and smudge-proof eyeliner
• A pencil eyeliner (Retractable)
• The product is free from phthalates, parabens, nonylphenol, Ethoxylates, triclosan, triclocarban, and hydroquinone, etc.
• A vegan and PETA certified cruelty free product

Cons:

• Didn’t find any

Julep When Pencil Met Gel Long-Lasting Waterproof Gel Eyeliner

A highly pigmented gel eyeliner that can give you a matte or a shimmer look on your eyes. Plus, it is ophthalmologically tested hence safe for your eyes.

Pros:

• Available in different shades of black, brown, etc.
• Available in matte and shimmer finish
• A water and smudge-proof eyeliner
• Clinically proven to last for more than 10 hours
• A gel eyeliner
• The product is free from paraben, SLS, and other harmful ingredients
• Cruelty-free and ophthalmologically tested product

Cons:

• Hard to find any

Physicians Formula Shimmer Strips Custom Eye Enhancing Eyeliner Trio Universal Looks Collection

If subtle is your thing, and you are in search of a nude eyeliner, then go for this product by Physicians Formula. With a glitter and shimmer finish, in nude colors, this trio would give you the fairy-tale look you long to have.

Pros:

• Available in a trio set of nude and black shades
• A water and smudge-proof eyeliner
• 24-hour stay
• A pencil eyeliner
• The product is free from paraben, SLS, and other harmful ingredients
• A cruelty-free, hypoallergenic, and dermatologically tested product
• Safe for sensitive eyes and those wearing contact lens

Cons:

• Didn’t find any

Neutrogena Nourishing Eyeliner Pencil

Formulated with olive oil and shea butter, this eyeliner is like food for your eyes. It will nourish your eyes and make them appear fuller and beautiful.

Pros:

• Available in different shades like cosmic black, chocolate, etc.
• A fade and smudge-proof eyeliner
• A pencil eyeliner with sharpener and smudger
• An ophthalmologically and dermatologically tested product
• Safe for sensitive eyes and those wearing contact lens

Cons:

• Hard to define any

Revlon Colorstay Eyeliner Pencil

Yet another crayon-based eye pencil that defines your eyes and underlines the waterline area without any irritation with 8 different shades to choose from.

Pros:

• Available in 8 different shades like black, brown, charcoal, teal, etc.
• A water and smudge-proof eyeliner
• 16-hour stay
• A pencil eyeliner with sharpener and smudger
• An ophthalmologically tested product

Cons:

• Didn’t find any

Conclusion

Hope you got the perfect eyeliner that aligns with your expectations and needs. You might even choose 2 different options for different occasions. We have got the matte and the shimmers both, in varied colors. Just don’t forget to look for safer options especially if you have sensitive eyes.